A little over a year ago, I
posted about Maybelline Fuchsia Fever which was believed at the time to be a pretty good MAC Candy Yum Yum dupe. Of course I didn't have Candy Yum Yum to compare it to, but I was happy with it and went merrily on my way.
Fast forward to Sunday night, I found an app for my new phone that lets me catalog my books. That basically was keeping me awake and entertained for hours, but I did take breaks in between to check out blogs and what not. On one of said blogs (or more specifically the
MAC Cosmetics Livejournal) I happened across a reminder that the MAC By Request collection was launching. This was a highly anticipated collection where MAC was bringing back LE lipsticks, lipglasses and eyeshadows as voted on by their Facebook fans. I had been on Facebook hiatus for most of the voting period, but still had my hopes up that they would bring 3N lipstick back. On that front I was disappointed - Candy Yum Yum, Moxie and Rocker won. Still, I happened to be online when they launched (only the lipsticks launched Sunday, in fact the eyeshadows are still yet to come) and picked up Candy Yum Yum and Moxie with a free 2-day shipping code.
Sometime Monday I was checking back on Livejournal again and started seeing posts cropping up that Candy Yum Yum (I hate the name of this color btw...) had sold out by morning and actually oversold as people were having their orders cancelled on them. I checked mine and it was fine (had a tracking number and everything), but I also ordered early and only one of each of the two colors. Most of the people whose orders were cancelled seemed to have ordered several Candy Yum Yum. The round and round about how poorly MAC handled this collection ensued (as it does every big lunch including the last one Candy Yum Yum was in) and is in fact still going. At this point Candy Yum Yum and Moxie are sold out (with the latter rumored to be pending a restock) and Rocker is still available. All three lipglasses also look to be available still (I don't like MAC Lipglasses AT ALL... OMG STICKY MESS)
Last night I came home from work to find my MAC box waiting for me (outside in the sun, luckily not melted) Both of my items were there and correct and actually super well packed. I honestly have no reason to badmouth MAC over my experience. I do feel a little like a jerk, though, because I only bought these on a whim and not because I was really awaiting their release with baited breath or anything like that. Just right place, right time... ya know? Reading (knowledge) really is power! I wouldn't have been online that late if I weren't updating my virtual bookshelf.
Anyway, enough words - more pictures. I took these both to show you Candy Yum Yum and also to answer my question about whether I had a dupe (or anything close). I would like to point out one more thing - there is now talk that the new Candy Yum Yum is NOT the same as the old release. Again, I don't know. Word is it's darker/less neon and creamier this release.
The goods - I took pictures of both boxes, but will only be showing Candy Yum Yum today:
Next to Fuchsia Fever - Don't judge... I actually USE Fuchsia Fever and wasn't planning to be photographing it again:
(Candy Yum Yum, Fuchsia Fever)
(Candy Yum Yum, Fuchsia Fever)
Aww, predictable little hearts - Keep not judging, this time about my Simpsons PJ pants:
(Fuchsia Fever, Candy Yum Yum)
At this point I was like... bummer. Or not any more I guess, but they look really different. I didn't care about the matte/gloss difference, but the color itself was noticeably different with Fuchsia Fever being more blue based. I thought I had such a good dupe all this time, though, so I was like man... but then:
Wait, they kind of look more similar now. I mean I can tell them apart, but still.
How about you guys? Do you know which is which and where I applied each? Do you think they're close enough for those who missed this new release? Honestly, I do.